Silva... Gerrard's gonna end up being dropped soon... we can be much better without him, he's not a DM!.. i think it's time he took a step back from the team!... but i don' think Brendan has the balls!..

Gerrard has accomplished more but Silva is genuine class

I'd take Silva over a Gerrard in his prime,Any day.

Today: Silva

Career: Gerrard

Silva by light years

Gerrard. He can have a direct impact on a game. Just like his direct impact of being absolutely invisible in today's game

Silva used to be incredible.

Stevie G obviously, he's like lightyears better than Silva.

Which one plays for the club that has won it FIVE TIMES?

Silva...

Neither, they both play nothing like their best days.